What Is an Essay Mill? How They Work and Which Countries They Target

TL;DR

Essay mills are commercial services producing academic work for students. The biggest brands include EduBirdie, EssayShark, PapersOwl, and GradeMiners. They are illegal in Australia, Ireland, and the UK. The AMI estimates that between 27% and 60% of students in different countries have used such services.

How essay mills work

The business model is straightforward:

1. A student visits an essay mill website
2. They upload their assignment brief, specifying subject, word count, academic level, and deadline
3. The service provides a price quote
4. Payment is made (credit card, PayPal, or cryptocurrency)
5. A writer — typically a graduate student, academic, or subject specialist — produces original work
6. The completed work is delivered, often with unlimited revisions
7. The student submits it under their own name

The work is genuinely original — it does not appear in any plagiarism database. This is what makes essay mills fundamentally different from, and more difficult to detect than, traditional plagiarism.

The major brands

Lancaster's research has identified over 900 active essay mill websites. The highest-traffic brands globally include:

• EduBirdie — primarily targets US, UK, Canadian, and Australian students
• EssayShark — global English-language market
• PapersOwl — US and Canadian market
• GradeMiners — global English-language
• UK Essays — UK, Ireland, and Commonwealth markets
• MyAssignmentHelp — Australian and South Asian markets
• SpeedyPaper — US market

Most operate from jurisdictions where essay mill services are not illegal, while serving students globally.

Which countries they target

The AMI essay mill presence score is based on 22 known essay mill sites and their documented primary target markets. Countries with the highest essay mill market presence scores:

• UK, Australia, Canada, Ireland — Anglophone markets with high disposable income
• US — largest absolute market by student population
• India, Pakistan — large English-language student populations
• Malaysia, Singapore — English-medium HE systems with high international student populations

The economics

While precise revenue figures are unavailable (most essay mills are private companies), estimates based on site traffic and price points suggest the global industry generates several hundred million dollars annually. The supply side is driven by academics in lower-income countries earning significant supplemental income by writing assignments.

Why detection is difficult

Essay mill work passes conventional plagiarism detection because it is original text. Detection methods that do work include:

• Stylometric analysis — comparing linguistic patterns against authenticated student work
• Oral examination — asking students to explain their work verbally
• Metadata forensics — examining document creation properties
• Intelligence from operators — under legal pressure, some services have cooperated with authorities

The detection rate is estimated at under 1% of cases — meaning the vast majority of essay mill use goes undetected and unpunished.

What the AMI data shows

The AMI D1 (Contract Cheating) dimension combines Google Trends data for generic contract cheating keywords, brand-name search data for specific essay mill companies, and the essay mill presence score. D1 is the highest-weighted dimension in the AMI at 19.5% of the P-Score.

Countries with the highest D1 scores: China, Pakistan, Russia, Egypt, Nigeria, Colombia, Argentina.

Countries with the lowest D1 scores: Australia, Ireland, New Zealand, Canada — all of which have specific legislation banning essay mill services.

View the full methodology | Download the dataset

Related

Read the full methodology